Key Lime Pie Popsicles (paleo, GF)

key-lime-pie-popsicles-perchancetocook-1I’ve been kind of obsessed with key lime pie lately. I’ve made key lime pie chicken, key lime pie pulled chicken, and once I figured out how to make a paleo version, even an actual key lime mousse pie. The key lime mousse pie was so delicious frozen, that I wanted to have a whole back-up of it in the freezer just ready, fresh, and waiting for me.

So I turned the pie into Key Lime Pie Popsicles!  It’s genius really, creamy frozen key lime pie in perfectly sized proportions. You just can’t beat paleo, non-processed, dessert at your fingertips.  

key-lime-pie-popsicles-perchancetocookSo when I say I turned the pie into popsicles, I really meant it. These are made out of key lime curd, the same thing that key lime pie is made out of. And the reason for that is that I’ve created a monster. Ever since I learned how to make curd, all I want to do is make it again and again and again. key-lime-pie-popsicles-perchancetocook-2It’s not made just out of key lime curd though, I folded in some coconut cream whipped cream. The combination of fruit juices and coconut cream makes for a decadent summer dessert. This means that my dessert cravings are satisfied and kept at bay. Which is a welcome treat, anytime.key-lime-pie-popsicles-perchancetocook-3I’m not sure if you can tell from the photos, but the texture of these is actually quite creamy. Which I love! I think that this technique would taste great with other fruit as well. Orange-lime, lemon, strawberry-lemon… I’m going to tackle some of those combos next!key-lime-pie-popsicles-perchancetocook-4

5.0 from 1 reviews
Key Lime Pie Popsicles
Cook time
Total time
Serves: 6
  • ½ cup of key lime juice
  • the juice of 2-3 cherries (for color)
  • ½ cup of honey
  • pinch of salt
  • 3 eggs
  • 1 Tbs melted coconut oil
  • 1 can of coconut milk
  • 1 Tbs vanilla
  • 2 Tbs maple syrup
  1. Put the can of coconut milk into the fridge for 2 hours.
  2. Whisk the key lime juice, cherry juice, honey, coconut oil, salt, and eggs together in a bowl. Pour into a non-reactive pan, I used a le creuset brand pan. Cook over medium- low heat while whisking non-stop until the mixture thickens. This should take about 10 minutes. Remove from heat and set the pan aside.
  3. While the lime curd cools, take the coconut milk can out of the fridge and pour the top creamy part of it out into a bowl (the liquid and the cream part will separate). Add the 1 tbs vanilla and 1 tbs maple syrup to the cream and mix with an electric hand held mixer until the mixture thickens. Don't worry about perfect whipped cream forming here, it doesn't matter too much.
  4. Once the lime curd is cool, fold 1 cup of the whipped coconut cream into it and then put this mixture into popsicle molds. This fit into 6 popsicle molds for me.
  5. Put the popsicle molds into the freezer overnight.
  6. Enjoy! :)

3 thoughts on “Key Lime Pie Popsicles (paleo, GF)

  1. It looks like this recipe would be delicious. I have looked locally for some Popsicle molds. Target and Walmart didn’t have them in my area. Where did you get yours? Thanks, Rebecca

    1. I bought mine on a whim at Target. I remember looking for popsicle molds and not being able to find any, but then when I wasn’t looking, they were there. Funny how things can be like that sometimes haha. I don’t see the same ones that I bought on Target’s website, but they did have others on there. I also noticed a bunch on amazon. I hope you can find some!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: